Underpinning advice
My new home is cracking — what the 10-year warranty actually covers
Published
A floor level survey on a seven-year-old Clyde North house should not, in principle, turn up much. New estate homes are built to a site classification, engineered to a slab design that matches it, and signed off by a building surveyor before anyone moves in. In practice, a meaningful share of our call-outs across Clyde North, Cranbourne and Berwick are homes well inside that “should still be fine” window, with stair-step cracking through the brickwork or a door that’s started binding at the top corner. The house isn’t failing in any dramatic sense. But the owner standing in the hallway pointing at it has usually never heard of the one thing most likely to pay for fixing it: Victoria’s statutory warranty on structural defects, which runs for ten years from completion — not six, not two, and not “until the builder stops answering the phone.”
This article isn’t about whether your crack is serious — why new homes on clay still crack covers the mechanics of why compliant slabs move and when that movement crosses into genuine defect territory. This one is about what to do with that information once you have it, because the warranty only works for people who use it the right way, in the right order, early enough to matter.
What the ten-year structural warranty actually is
Domestic building work in Victoria carries a statutory warranty period, separate from any contract the builder gave you and separate from home and contents insurance. Structural defects are covered for ten years from the date the work was completed — roughly, from the certificate of occupancy or final inspection, not from when you signed the contract or moved your furniture in. Non-structural issues — paint, minor finishes, the kind of thing that was always going to need touching up — carry a much shorter period, commonly around two years, and for most owners reading this it has already lapsed.
The warranty sits with the builder directly: if the build itself was deficient — a site classification that didn’t match the ground that was actually there, a footing design that didn’t account for it, drainage that wasn’t installed the way the plans specified — that’s the kind of thing the warranty exists for. It is a different, and separate, question from building insurance, which in Victoria generally only comes into play if the builder has died, disappeared or become insolvent and can’t be pursued directly. Most owners never need that second layer, because most builders are still contactable. What they do need is to use the first one properly, and most people only find out it exists after they’ve already made the mistakes below.
Why year three beats year nine
The warranty period is long enough that owners tend to treat it as a deadline far in the future rather than a clock that’s already running. That’s the single biggest mistake we see. Acting early matters for reasons that have nothing to do with the legal mechanics and everything to do with evidence:
- The pattern is clearer close to when it started. A crack photographed at first appearance and again six months later shows a rate of change. The same crack photographed for the first time in year eight shows only its current width, with no way to establish whether it opened gradually or all at once — which matters enormously when a builder’s defence is “that’s always been like that” or “that happened after handover, not because of us.”
- Witnesses and records exist. The site supervisor, the subcontractor who poured the slab, the original soil report held in the builder’s files rather than yours — all of it is easier to locate and more reliable three years after completion than nine.
- You still have time to be wrong. If an early assessment says the movement looks seasonal rather than structural, you can monitor for a season and reassess with the clock still running. If you wait until year nine to get that same assessment and it turns out you needed to escalate, there may be no time left to do it properly.
- A long, undocumented gap reads badly. Even where a claim is technically still within time, a builder (or whoever eventually adjudicates a dispute) will reasonably ask why nothing was raised for most of a decade. “I didn’t know the warranty existed” is a true answer, but it’s a worse position than having something in writing from year three.
None of this means a genuine defect stops being covered just because you’re further into the window. It means the practical difficulty of proving it rises every year you wait, and the ten years is a ceiling, not a target.
Document first. Don’t pay for private underpinning first.
This is the part owners get backwards most often, and it’s costly when they do. If your Clyde North, Cranbourne or Berwick home is inside the ten-year window and showing structural movement, the sequence that protects you is:
- Photograph and measure before anything else moves. Date every photo, include something for scale, and mark the end of each crack in pencil so you can tell later whether it’s grown.
- Get an independent floor level survey and engineer’s report. Independent means not engaged by whoever stands to win the repair work — a report commissioned by the business that then quotes to fix the problem it just diagnosed is not the evidence you want if this ends up disputed. Our underpinning page covers how we run that assessment, and it’s the same floor-level-and-crack-mapping process regardless of who ends up doing the repair.
- Raise it with the builder in writing, with the report attached, before doing anything irreversible. Give them a reasonable opportunity to respond — most builders will send their own inspector, and some will agree to fix it without a fight.
- If that goes nowhere, there are formal dispute pathways for exactly this situation in Victoria. We’re not the right source for the legal detail of how to run one — a solicitor or a tenants’ and owners’ advocacy service is — but the existence of that pathway is the reason step 2 matters: you need an independent report in hand before you start it, not after.
The costly version of this is paying a contractor privately for underpinning first, then discovering the builder would have covered it. Underpinning typically runs $15,000 to $40,000 — not a sum worth spending before you’ve tested whether someone else is on the hook for it. And once the repair is done, the evidence of exactly how the ground had moved and why is gone. Repairing first and asking questions later is understandable when a crack feels urgent, but structural movement from reactive clay is measured in seasons, not weeks, and taking the time to document it properly very rarely costs you anything except peace of mind in the short term.
When the warranty genuinely won’t help
Not every crack in a young home is a warranty matter, and it’s worth being honest about that rather than encouraging every reader to escalate. If the site was classified correctly and the slab was built to that classification, and the movement traces back to something that happened after handover — a garden bed you built against the wall, irrigation added in year four, a downpipe disconnected during a later landscaping job — that’s an owner-caused moisture problem, not a construction defect, and the warranty was never going to cover it. The honest answer in that situation is fixing the moisture source and, if the structure needs it, paying for underpinning yourself. The point of documenting early isn’t to manufacture a claim; it’s to find out which situation you’re actually in while there’s still time to do something about either one.
Cracking in a home that’s still inside its first decade, in Clyde North, Cranbourne, Berwick or anywhere else on Melbourne’s reactive clay? Book a free assessment and we’ll give you a straight read on what’s moving and why — independent of whether you end up pursuing the builder or paying for the repair yourself.
Common questions
Does the ten-year warranty cover cosmetic cracking, or only structural damage?
Only structural. Victoria's statutory warranty period for domestic building work distinguishes structural defects, which it covers for the full ten years, from non-structural defects, which carry a much shorter period of around two years and are usually long expired by the time an owner notices anything. A hairline crack in paint that doesn't follow a mortar joint and doesn't widen is typically cosmetic. Stair-step cracking through brickwork, cracks that run through a window or door head, or doors binding at a top corner are the kind of thing that falls on the structural side and is worth having assessed against the warranty rather than written off as cosmetic.
My home is nine years old — is it too late to do anything?
Not necessarily, but the margin for error is gone. If the structural warranty period genuinely hasn't expired yet, the claim is still technically available, but you no longer have time to spend a season watching and deciding. Get the floor level survey and the independent engineer's report booked immediately, and put the builder on written notice before the window closes rather than after. If you're already past the ten-year mark, the warranty route is closed and the options are a private engineer's assessment and either monitoring or paying for the repair yourself — which is exactly the gap this article is trying to help people avoid landing in.
Can I just ask the builder to come and look at it informally first?
You can, and plenty of builders will come out and have a genuine look. The risk is treating that visit as the record. An informal chat with no written follow-up, no independent engineer involved, and no dated documentation of what was said is very hard to rely on two years later if the problem continues and the relationship sours. It's fine to call the builder first as a courtesy — just follow it immediately with a written account of the visit, and get your own independent assessment running in parallel rather than waiting to see if their informal opinion turns out to be right.
Think this is happening at your place?
We assess before we quote — floor levels measured, cracks mapped, and a straight answer on whether you need work at all. Read more aboutunderpinning & foundation repair, or get in touch.