Underpinning advice

Screw piles vs bored concrete piers: which one does your house need?

Published

Ask two underpinning contractors to quote the same house and it’s common to get two different methods back: one proposes screw piles, the other bored concrete piers. Both can be the right answer — on different ground. Mass concrete underpinning and resin injection are explained elsewhere on this site; this article goes deep on the two methods that most residential underpinning jobs in Melbourne actually end up choosing between, because between them they cover the overwhelming majority of sites where competent ground sits anywhere from about one and a half to five metres down.

For the full four-way comparison including mass concrete and resin injection, see underpinning methods compared. This article doesn’t introduce new pricing — it stays consistent with the figures already published there and on the underpinning service page, and goes further into what actually separates these two.

What each one is, mechanically

Bored concrete piers are holes augered down to competent ground, reinforced with steel, and filled with concrete. Once cured, the structure’s load is transferred onto the pier through a needle beam or a bracket fitted beneath the existing footing. It’s the workhorse method for Melbourne residential underpinning because it’s well understood, carries high loads reliably, and most building surveyors have seen hundreds of them.

Screw piles are steel shafts with one or more helical plates welded along their length, hydraulically screwed into the ground until they reach a specified installation torque — a number that correlates to a known bearing capacity for that soil. There’s no excavation in the usual sense: the pile displaces soil as it advances rather than removing it. Once installed, the structure is bracketed onto the pile head, typically the same day, because there’s no concrete that needs to cure first.

The mechanical difference is the whole story behind almost everything that follows. A bored pier needs a hole that stays open long enough to reinforce and pour. A screw pile needs ground it can be driven into to a measured resistance. That single fact decides which method suits which site.

Depth to competent ground: known vs unknown

This is the first and most important question, and it’s a geotechnical answer rather than a preference.

Bored piers work well when competent ground sits at a depth the engineer can specify in advance — typically somewhere between roughly 2 and 5 metres for most Melbourne residential work. The auger goes to that depth, and the hole is dug to a known target. Where the depth to competent ground is consistent across a site, this is usually the more economical choice, because the equipment is simpler and the per-pier rate is lower.

Screw piles earn their place specifically where that depth is not reliably known in advance. Because a screw pile is installed to a measured torque rather than to a predetermined depth, it finds competent ground wherever it actually occurs — whether that’s 1.8 metres on one side of the house and 3.4 metres twenty centimetres away. That matters enormously on sites like Tarneit, where houses were built on former farmland that was cut and filled to create level building platforms, and a single lot can have a slab spanning undisturbed natural ground on one side and several metres of engineered fill on the other. A bored pier programmed to a single assumed depth across that kind of site is a guess; a screw pile driven to refusal at each location isn’t.

Melton sits in similar territory for a different reason — not fill variability but simply deep, difficult clay, where piers commonly need to reach three to four and a half metres to get below the zone of seasonal moisture change. On a site where that depth is reasonably consistent, bored piers remain a sound and often cheaper choice. Where test bores come back inconsistent from one location to the next, screw piles reduce the risk of a pier that’s technically at the specified depth but still sitting in moisture-affected ground because the “specified depth” was an average rather than a measurement at that exact spot.

Access and spoil

Bored piers generate real spoil — a meaningful volume of excavated soil has to come out of each hole and be removed from site, by wheelbarrow where there’s no vehicle access, by truck where there is. On a tight inner-suburban block, or anywhere the piers sit close to a fence, a garden bed the owner wants kept intact, or a path that can’t be torn up, that spoil has to go somewhere, and it adds time and cost.

Screw piles displace soil rather than removing most of it, so spoil volumes are a fraction of a bored pier’s. The equipment that installs them can also be considerably smaller than an auger rig capable of reaching four or five metres, which matters where the piering locations are down a narrow side passage or in a cramped rear yard with no vehicle access at all. This is less of a deciding factor in suburbs like Werribee and Hoppers Crossing, where older brick veneer homes generally sit on wider blocks with reasonable access and shallower, more predictable footings — conditions where bored piers do the job without the access constraint ever becoming the deciding factor.

Time on site, and why curing matters

A bored pier needs to cure before load is transferred onto it — commonly several days to reach adequate strength, which is part of why mass concrete underpinning and bored pier jobs both run to a staged sequence rather than being installed and loaded in one visit. A screw pile is installed to its specified torque and can usually be loaded the same day, because there’s no concrete strength to wait for.

For a straightforward job where time isn’t the binding constraint, that difference doesn’t change the outcome, only the schedule. It becomes a real factor where a house is actively and visibly getting worse, where the owner needs to be back in a room sooner rather than later, or where staging the work around a curing schedule is itself a problem — a kitchen renovation booked in behind the piering, for instance. Screw piles compress a job that might run two to three weeks with bored piers into something closer to a week.

Cost, side by side

Bored concrete piers Screw piles
Typical cost $1,500 – $3,500 per pier $2,000 – $4,000 per pile
Depth suitability Reliable for a known, consistent depth Finds competent ground at variable or unknown depth
Spoil Significant — removed by barrow or truck Minimal
Curing before load transfer Days None — same-day loading
Equipment Auger rig, needs some working clearance Smaller hydraulic rig, suits tight access

Both figures are indicative, consistent with the ranges on underpinning methods compared and the underpinning service page. Screw piles sit above bored piers per unit, which is the trade-off for the speed and the reduced site disruption — on a straightforward, shallow, predictable site, that premium buys you nothing you needed, which is exactly why bored piers remain the default rather than screw piles becoming it everywhere.

How the decision should actually be made

The method should follow the ground, not the other way around. A geotechnical investigation establishes the depth to competent ground and whether that depth is consistent across the site or varies — test bores or hand auger holes at several locations, not one assumption extrapolated across the whole footprint. An access assessment follows: what can physically get to each pier location, and does the spoil from a bored pier have anywhere sensible to go. Only once both of those are answered does the method genuinely get chosen, and on a reasonable number of sites the honest answer is a mix — bored piers where ground is shallow and access is good, screw piles at the one corner where fill runs deep or a side passage won’t fit an auger rig.

A contractor who names the method before inspecting the site is telling you which equipment they own, not what your house needs. If a quote arrives with a single method and no mention of depth to competent ground or access constraints, ask what the test bores showed — if the answer is that none were done, the method hasn’t actually been chosen yet, whatever the quote says.


Not sure which method your site needs? Book a free on-site assessment — we’ll establish depth to competent ground, check access, and recommend the method that fits your house, not the one we’d rather be installing that week.

Common questions

Can a contractor switch from bored piers to screw piles partway through a job?

Sometimes, and it's worth asking about before work starts rather than being surprised by a variation. If an auger strikes rock, a buried obstruction, or ground that keeps collapsing back into the hole before it can be filled, bored piers can become impractical at a specific location even though the method suited the rest of the site. Screw piles can often be substituted at just that point, since they don't rely on an open, stable hole. What shouldn't happen is a contractor discovering this on day one and treating it as a surprise cost — a competent geotechnical investigation flags variable or obstructed ground before anyone starts digging, so a switch should be the exception, not the norm.

Do screw piles carry as much load as concrete piers?

A properly specified screw pile does, for the loads a residential underpinning job actually imposes. Screw piles are installed to a measured torque that correlates to a known bearing capacity, and the engineer sizes the pile diameter, helix configuration and installation torque to the load it needs to carry — the same way a bored pier is sized by diameter and depth. Where very high concentrated loads are involved, such as under a large masonry chimney or a heavily loaded transfer beam, a bored concrete pier is sometimes still the more economical way to get the same capacity. For typical brick veneer and weatherboard residential loads, both methods comfortably do the job when designed correctly.

Why would a contractor recommend bored piers if screw piles are faster?

Because speed isn't the only variable, and a contractor recommending bored piers over screw piles isn't automatically behind the times. Where competent ground is shallow and reasonably predictable, bored piers are usually cheaper per pier, don't need specialist piling equipment to be trucked to site, and are the more familiar method to most building surveyors and engineers, which can mean a smoother permit process. Screw piles earn their higher cost per pile specifically where depth is uncertain, access is tight, or the job needs to be finished in days rather than weeks. A straight recommendation should say which of those applies to your site, not just assert that one method is better.

Think this is happening at your place?

We assess before we quote — floor levels measured, cracks mapped, and a straight answer on whether you need work at all. Read more aboutunderpinning & foundation repair, or get in touch.

← All foundation advice

Call 03 4149 0244Get a quote