Restumping advice
Why is my floor sloping?
Published
“The stumps” is the default answer the moment a Melbourne homeowner mentions a sloping floor, and often it’s the right one — this is a city full of century-old weatherboards on timber posts that were never going to last forever. But stumps are one of four genuinely different causes, and the other three are either cheaper to fix, impossible to fix the way you’re imagining, or not actually a problem at all. Guessing wrong means paying for the wrong repair, which is a more common outcome in this trade than it should be.
The four causes, and how they actually differ
1. Failed stumps. The posts holding up a suspended timber floor have rotted at ground level, settled into a footing that was never adequate, or — on old concrete stumps — cracked as internal reinforcement corrodes and expands. The floor has followed them down. This movement is one-directional: it has only ever gotten worse, never partially recovered, and it won’t on its own.
2. Sagging or over-spanned joists and bearers. The stumps themselves are fine, but the timber spanning between them has deflected. This is common after a wall gets removed for an open-plan reno and the floor structure above it loses support it used to lean on invisibly, after a bathroom gets tiled onto an original timber floor without checking whether the joists were sized for the extra weight, or where joists have been notched through for plumbing or wiring until there’s not much timber left to do the spanning. The tell is that it’s often localised to one room or one line across a room, and it tends to feel bouncy as well as sloped.
3. Ground movement under a slab. If you’re on a concrete slab rather than a timber floor, there’s nothing underneath to rot — the ground itself is swelling or shrinking, usually because of reactive clay, and lifting or dropping sections of the slab with it. This is the one genuinely different mechanism on the list, because unless you’ve read our guide to reactive clay in Melbourne’s west you might not know it exists. It also tends to reverse with the seasons, which none of the other three causes do.
4. It was never level. Genuinely common, and the one people least want to hear. Pre-war houses built across a sloping block, or additions and sunrooms built by a previous owner without much regard for datum, were often not dead level on the day they were finished. If the slope has been there as long as anyone can remember and hasn’t changed, there may be nothing moving at all — just a floor that started slightly wrong and has stayed exactly where it started.
Why the gap between “feels off” and “is actually moving” matters
Every one of the four causes above can produce the same sensation underfoot — a marble rolling, a door that doesn’t quite latch, a wardrobe you’ve wedged with a folded beer coaster. That’s the problem with diagnosing a sloping floor by feel: the symptom is identical and the fixes range from “nothing, it’s fine” to a $20,000 restump.
What actually separates the four is direction and pattern, not how it feels:
- Only ever one way, never recovering → stumps or a structural fault, not the ground.
- Localised to one room or follows a line across a room rather than the whole house → a joist or bearer problem, not the stumps generally.
- Opens up in summer and partly closes in winter → the ground moving under a slab.
- Been exactly the same for as long as you or a previous long-term owner can verify → it was probably never level, and may not need fixing at all.
This is why a proper assessment starts with a floor level survey rather than a walk-through. Laser levels taken on a grid across the house, plotted into a contour map, show whether the floor has dropped at one point, tilted consistently across the whole footprint, or lifted at the edges — three patterns that look similar standing in the room and mean three different things on paper. Our floor levelling service page covers how that survey works and what each pattern of movement typically costs to correct, from a $1,500 targeted repair up to a full restump.
You can do a rough version of this yourself before calling anyone. A marble set down in several rooms, or a cheap spirit level across a doorway threshold, tells you which direction things are moving. Do it once, write down the room, the direction and roughly how many millimetres over how many metres, and repeat it in three to six months. A record across a season is the single most useful piece of information you can hand to anyone who eventually looks at the house, because it answers the one question that decides almost everything: is this still happening?
The suburbs where each cause tends to show up
None of these are universal rules — every street has exceptions — but the pattern holds often enough to be useful.
In Northcote, the land falls hard away from the High Street ridge, and a genuine, long-standing construction slope across a house built on that fall is common enough that it’s often cause four rather than failed stumps — though tall rear stumps on the low side of a sloping block do also fail, so the two causes sit side by side here more than almost anywhere else.
In Thornbury, a lot of double-fronted bungalows were extended at the rear decades after the original stumps went in, on a different stump generation entirely. A step or ridge at the join between old and new is frequently cause four — the two sections were never built to one level in the first place — rather than anything actively failing.
Preston and Reservoir show cause one in a specific, even-settlement form: post-war concrete stumps that haven’t rotted at all, sitting on footing pads poured to a 1950s budget, sinking gradually and uniformly across a whole end of the house rather than dipping sharply in one spot. It reads as “the floor feels a bit off everywhere” rather than an obvious dip, which is exactly why it gets left undiagnosed for years.
The honest version of what to do next
If your floor has been the same shape for as long as you can actually verify — not assume — and nothing else in the house has changed, the responsible advice is sometimes to do nothing. Spending money correcting a floor that was built slightly out of level eighty years ago and has stayed exactly there buys you nothing except a short-lived flat floor and a bill. We’d rather tell a caller that than sell them a restump they don’t need.
If the movement is active — getting worse, concentrated at a join or under one room, or tracking the seasons — then which of the first three causes applies determines everything else: whether it’s a $1,500 targeted repair or a job running into five figures, and whether it’s restumping or underpinning that actually applies. Measure first, diagnose second, quote third. Doing it in that order is the only way to avoid paying for the wrong fix.
Common questions
I can see a gap under the skirting but my doors are fine — do I still have a stump problem?
Possibly, and the mismatch is worth paying attention to rather than dismissing. A gap under the skirting shows the floor dropping away from the wall frame, which is a floor-structure sign; doors go out of square when the whole wall frame racks, which takes more movement or a different pattern of it. A localised stump failure under one corner can open a skirting gap in that room well before it's distorted the door frame enough to notice. Treat the skirting gap as the earlier warning, not a false alarm, and get the subfloor looked at rather than waiting for the doors to confirm it.
My floor has sloped for the 20 years I've lived here and nothing has changed — can I just leave it?
If you genuinely have 20 years of lived experience that it hasn't moved — the same doors have always stuck in the same spot, the same gap under the skirting hasn't widened, no new cracks — then yes, leaving it is a defensible decision, not a risk you're taking on blind. That's the 'it was never level' or 'it moved once and stopped' case, and spending $15,000 to fix a floor that isn't going anywhere is money with no return. The caveat is that 'nothing has changed' needs to be something you've actually checked, not just assumed, particularly if you're relying on someone else's twenty years rather than your own.
Does home insurance cover a sloping floor?
Generally no, and it's worth knowing that before you frame the call to an insurer around it. Standard home and contents policies cover sudden, identifiable damage — a storm, a burst pipe, a fire — not gradual deterioration like stump rot, footing settlement or soil movement over years, which insurers treat as wear, maintenance or an excluded ground-movement event depending on the policy. There are rare exceptions where a specific insured event (a burst pipe washing out soil under a slab, for instance) caused the movement, which is a separate question to the slope itself. Read your policy's exclusions before assuming either way, and don't delay getting it assessed while you wait on an insurer's answer.
Think this is happening at your place?
We assess before we quote — floor levels measured, cracks mapped, and a straight answer on whether you need work at all. Read more aboutrestumping & reblocking, or get in touch.